Thx. I’m not familiar with what “fixed weeks” means...can you help me understand?
I’ve got friends who own at BCV, and I’ve been renting points from many others at BCV and BWV over the last 15 years, and have always been able to get my preferred dates (give/take a day or two) at the 11th month window, except once in 2017. I had never experienced a shutout anything like this, and BCV has a very similar size and popularity to CCV.
Capacity doesn’t meet demand—fine. But DVC has an ethical if not legal obligation to disclose what to expect with regard to actually being able to use your points. “December is busy” is not the same as “You’ll need to book right at 8am or by 8:05 forget it and wait to see if you can get into SSR or OKW at 7 months.” This is like trying to get Hamilton tickets online—except that you’ve already paid for your ticket and they won’t give you a seat.
A fixed week - is essentially that...a week that you own every year. I own another timeshare in Aruba and they only offer fixed weeks...I think it is more common in traditional timeshare ownership than DVC, but DVC started offering this when they sold VGF...as far as I know VGF, POLY and CCV and now RR are the only ones who have fixed weeks. If you check VGF availability and RR availability, you'll see a similar demand problem for December as we see at CCV. Unfortunately fixed weeks in December are a hot commodity, compared with other times of the year. Essentially if you wanted to go in December yearly, you could have bought a fixed week (I believe a fixed week studio for December was going for 118 points - normal cost for that week was 107 points, but they have a built in 10% increase buffer that would make you buy 118 points to secure that week) when they were offering them. You can convert your points out of a fixed week if you wanted to, in order to use them other times during the year, but I'd imagine most people who bought December fixed weeks kept them, either for personal use or to rent given how popular the points are.
As for your other point about the ethical/legal point...I don't see the argument. All they are selling you is the possibility that you can get a room at 11 months or that you will be able to use your yearly points at your home resort at some point during the year. In theory, you can, and in theory even in December you could get one at 7-months at SSR. That might not be what you want...but that is what DVC essentially is - a flexible timeshare. You referenced October, in your post, so I checked October, and the only dates not available for a 1-bedroom in October right now are Columbus day, and 2 other days. So 26 out of 31 days are available for booking any trip. My guess is you wanted Columbus day weekend (any holiday weekend will require an 11-month booking at 8AM)...and even then you're up against probably 500-1000 owners at least for a few hundred rooms, so you're playing quickest trigger finger at 8AM. Any other time in October is there for you...again that's not DVC's fault, it's just the reality of owning a flexible timeshare. Right now, you could book a 1-bedroom at CCV from April thru October with relative ease (april is spotty, but about 50% open right now).
Unfortunately with the Cabin issue, Flexibility regarding dates in using your points will be the key for all CCV owners, in whether ownership is enjoyable or not. I'm hoping the best for you, and you're able to win the battle of quickest fingers over the next few days to get your December reservation...I know it sucks, and causes extra stress, but it's the unfortunate reality of CCV and VGF in December.