Best: 50's Prime Time - we were with our two sons (ages 16 and 27) and our oldest son's girlfriend. While we have always enjoyed our meals here, this was the first time our oldest son his girlfriend went to WDW with us and the restaurant is even more fun with a larger group.
Worst: Sadly Chef Mickey. I know the place always gets horrible reviews but I have always defended it. Our past visits the food has been fine, nothing to rave about, but it was decent. This last trip is the first time I felt that the poor quality of the food was noticeable. It just seemed very "institutional" to me. I think there are better characters buffets and, for the price, it is just not worth it to me anymore. My husband and son still like it so I am guessing we will go back again.