No I don't deny any of the data. They aren't trying to screw the Resale market, they are trying to control it. What I think (and what do I know), Disney is constantly trying to:
- Get people to buy Direct
- Keep people in contracts for life (or until they expire)
- Somewhat control the resale market
They do it because it costs them money. I said it elsewhere, I'm a computer programmer. I can only imagine the coding logic involved in their software to manage all this crap. If they bought all their points and are in one Use Year at 1 resort, the owner can book at 11 months out at "home" and 7 months out anywhere and buy anything and access all perks. If they bought all Direct, with multiple Use Years at the same resort, they can book X points at this time at the Home resort, Y points at 7 months out anywhere for this contract, A points at 11 months out home and B points at 7 months out anywhere, etc, etc, etc. This has to be a nightmare to write the code! As this is just the tip of the iceberg. It's costing them a small fortune to support DVC.
Anyone getting screwed is incidental. If Disney knew then what they know now they would have done some things very differently.
Remember Celebration was a Disney invention on Disney owned land. And when it was all done, they annexed it back to Osceola County because they didn't want any part of it. They couldn't control it. It's why Disney has City licenses in Orange County but has very few actual residences and residents. The people who live there are tightly controlled.