They have made such an incredible mess of this. At what point would they have saved money overall by just extending all APs for an additional year - at some point, the lost money from renewal costs for one year would be offset by savings in the amount of employee-hours they've wasted by dealing with the constant calls and programming all the still-confusing emails and calculating all the complicated options for the passes and making up for the bank fees for the payment glitch and tracking everything and the refunds themselves, even before calculating in the ill-will they've created among the AP holders for all of this. If they'd just kept it simple and been maybe a little bit generous, it certainly would have come out better for them PR-wise and would be far less stressful for their employees and might not even have cost them anymore financially than this ridiculous nightmare is.