I don't get the complaints about BOG Lunch.
"It's Overpriced" -- You're at Disney. Everything is overpriced. BOG Lunch is only a few dollars more than other QS options such as Cosmic Ray's or Pinocchio Village Haus.
- BOG QS Lunch -- $26-27 for Braised Pork/French Dip, Drink, Master's Cupcake, and an Nice Venue ($23 w/o Desert)
- Other QS Options -- $20-25 for a sub-par Burger/Sandwich/Pasta, Drink, Desert, and No Atmosphere ($15-20 w/o Desert)
"It's Chaotic" -- Most QS places are chaotic. Unlike certain other QS options, I've never had to stand with food in hand waiting for a table at BOG. Compared to
Quick Service options, BOG Lunch is in my experience far less chaotic.
"The Food isn't that Great" -- Obviously, opinions may vary, but I found it to be just as good as what you get at Liberty Tree Tavern or Garden Grill, but 57-73% of the price and not AYCTE. BOG Lunch is a strange hybrid between TS and QS. Its technically QS, but has elements of TS (ADRs, Food brought to your table). I think many folks go in expecting too much of it. I like both the French Dip and Braised Pork. They are middle of the road, but decent and far better than what you'd get at Cosmic Ray's or most other QS options.
I try to get a BOG Lunch ADR any time I do the Fantasyland/Tomorrowland side of MK. I'll spend a few extra dollars not to grace the doors of Cosmic Ray's or Pinocchio Village Haus (aside from EMM Breakfast which was very good). On a side note, if you do the DDS (I mean
DDP), BOG Lunch is QS, so it should cost the same as any other QS option.