Trial Run for Dogs in Resort Rooms

Do you think dogs should be allowed in guests' rooms?


  • Total voters
    1,260
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Knoebels, a family owned Amusement Park in Northeastern PA has allowed dogs in their park for years, heck the dogs are even allowed on a few of the rides. No breed or size restrictions the dogs just have to be leashed and picked up after. My family has gone their for years and I've never saw any of the things that people are swearing is going to happen. But of course you're dealing with much smaller and less crowded area than WDW...

The problems there (as with so many other places where dogs don't need to be, but humans do) would generally be invisible to the people who don't have to deal with them. You probably don't see or hear them because they can't go at all!
 
I think this is a wonderful idea. My dog is more well behaved and polite than most adults and kids I've encountered at Disney the 35 plus times I've been there. He wouldn't ever be noticed! And is definitely cleaner than the kid who decided to use SAB as a toilet this past week. The pool was closed for at least 30 min! I've seen some crazy things, and rude people over the years, and a dog couldn't possibly be any worse. I've actually come to a point where I like dogs more than most humans. I hope they add the Polynesian and the French Quarter!


I agree with you that dogs are better than most humans in many ways. That being said, it is the human element that worries me. It is not the dogs themselves but the irresponsible owners that is the issue for me. We have all witnessed the guests at WDW who feel that rules, and, consideration of others, do not apply to them.
If what I read earlier about inconsiderate dog owners at Ft Wilderness is true( I am not doubting the person who posted), then we as guests will be negatively impacted.
And although my family and I do not suffer from animal allergies or phobias, I sympathize with those that do, and understand how severely they may be impacted.
 
I think this is a wonderful idea. My dog is more well behaved and polite than most adults and kids I've encountered at Disney the 35 plus times I've been there. He wouldn't ever be noticed! And is definitely cleaner than the kid who decided to use SAB as a toilet this past week. The pool was closed for at least 30 min! I've seen some crazy things, and rude people over the years, and a dog couldn't possibly be any worse. I've actually come to a point where I like dogs more than most humans. I hope they add the Polynesian and the French Quarter!

Incorrect. A dog can cause illness and God forbid a fatal allergy attack simply by being there. Additionally, a dog could easily become overstimulated at at place like Disney and break away from it's owner and bite or maul another Guest. Disney was not designed for animals; it was designed for people. Best Friend's Dog Park/Kennel was designed for dogs.

Food for thought: Just because you Can; doesn't mean you Should.
 


Why do you think this poll is NOT representative of the population as a whole? Being a Disney fan has no correlation as to whether you are allergic to dog, don't like the smell of animal urine/feces in your room, or conversely love your dog so much that you would want to travel to Disney with your dog. In other words, those who dislike this policy are voting negatively. Those who like it, are voting in the opposite direction.

If the focus of this Board was "People Who Dislike Animals", then I agree that this survey would be biased toward apposing this policy. This is a Disney board. I contend that the population on this Board (and it's opinion on this new dog policy) is representative of the population as a whole.
Attractions Magazine has a poll going with 1700+ people about the new policy and it's at 38% love it, 32% hate it, 30% don't care.
Others that I have seen pop up have been even heavier for in favor.
The DIS definitely does not represent the general population. This has always held true.
 
I know that the policy says that only certain rooms in certain areas of the resorts will be set aside for dog owners. My concern is that you have arrived at your resort at a high occupancy time, you have allergies, and all of the dog free rooms are occupied. Where do they put you then?

Perhaps the cost will keep many people from trying out this new policy. With an additional room rate of $50 a night and the doggie daycare at $27 a day, that's $77 a day. In my area, you could get a live-in pet sitter for that amount.
 
Do people really throw away perfectly good shoes if they happen to step in a dog's waste? Do they really expect Disney to do something about it? I would just ask housekeeping for some cleaning supplies, clean the offensive material off and move on with life.
 


I have a question for those who have been around a while, as I’ve only been here a little over a year.

The question was previously asked, when was the last time a change at WDW sparked so much controversy.

My question is, when was the last time a change at Disney was enacted that had the potential to have a negative affect on the heath and well-being of its guests? That’s the more pertinent question. Forget FP changes, dining policies, alcohol, etc. (although something could be said for that).
 
For those who have phobias, how do you deal with dogs in your community? I know on my street, 3 of the surrounding houses have dogs, dogs are always in their yards which are adjacent to mine. Dogs walk by my house all day. Wouldn't you just do the same thing at WDW that you do at home if necessary?

Of course! I may cross the street to avoid them or stay far back or choose a different route, etc...But that's not my idea of a vacation.

We spend a lot of time at our resort walking around. Just looking at the four dog relief areas located all over AofA and POR tells me that dogs are going to be all over the pathways at these resorts.
 
Disney has never demonstrated that they enforce any of their rules. For this reason alone I am totally against this. How will cast members ensure an unruly dog is brought under control if they have zero success with people breaking various rules that impact their fellow guests (line jumping, smoking, general bad behavior....)

Too much room for abuse by guests who are well aware how far the line can be pushed before Disney takes any action. And that action could also include some perk to make up for any lost guest satisfaction.
 
Attractions Magazine has a poll going with 1700+ people about the new policy and it's at 38% love it, 32% hate it, 30% don't care.
Others that I have seen pop up have been even heavier for in favor.
The DIS definitely does not represent the general population. This has always held true.

The DIS represents the opinions of people who actually go to Disney - (not everyone in the "general population" goes to Disney).
And by the way, when I go other places, and when I book a hotel, the first thing I look for is "Pet-Free" because I don't want to sleep in a dog bed; I want to sleep in a people bed.
 
Disney has never demonstrated that they enforce any of their rules. For this reason alone I am totally against this.
I really don't have a dog in this race. :laughing: I like dogs, but don't have one right now. I'm not deathly allergic or anything.

But just like you, I'm not a big fan of the new policy for this reason alone.
 
Do people really throw away perfectly good shoes if they happen to step in a dog's waste? Do they really expect Disney to do something about it? I would just ask housekeeping for some cleaning supplies, clean the offensive material off and move on with life.

I simply refuse to get on a plane and fly to Disney...and then spend 1 minute of my vacation cleaning dog pooooop off my shoes. That is Not magical!
 
Of course! I may cross the street to avoid them or stay far back or choose a different route, etc...But that's not my idea of a vacation.

We spend a lot of time at our resort walking around. Just looking at the four dog relief areas located all over AofA and POR tells me that dogs are going to be all over the pathways at these resorts.

I agree, dogs are going to be all over the walkways at these resorts. No doubt. I don't care where they say they are putting these "dog relief areas"...dogs need walks

So it sounds like the high density of the resorts is the difference for you (versus being at home where you might find it easier to avoid them). The resorts are more like a city really. I was thinking about the residential areas of Manhattan, that wouldn't be a good place for someone with a dog phobia, dogs are everywhere
 
I simply refuse to get on a plane and fly to Disney...and then spend 1 minute of my vacation cleaning dog pooooop off my shoes. That is Not magical!

I agree it's not magical but the question remains - what do you do if it does happen?
 
I get ya but my point was lumping in this new policy into a "I'm waiting for the front desk to pixie dust my soiled shoes?"...IDK I'm just saying..your concern of 'soiled shoes', while valid, hasn't and will not change new policy or no new policy as this is already something you would worry about (or at least it would appear you worried about..but maybe not because you didn't pack extras before to account for the gross stuff that on a practical level we all know we can encounter). So again if you're not packing extras before I wouldn't think you need to now.

I'm hoping you're just trying to be helpful to my situation, - you tone suggests perhaps otherwise, but your words reiterate my point. OF course my concerns will not change the new policy, and the pixie dust comment was more tongue in cheek as I'm trying to deal with not a hypothetical situation, but an actual change that will most likely affect me in some way - of course Disney won't assist me or care about the inconvenience. I can't change the resort (big group, too late), and my concerns don't warrant cancelation (no severe allergies, etc.), so my new reality is the policy for this trip that I'm staying at a pet friendly resort. My recourse it to think about possibilities and how to make the best of them, but again, I feel like the potential consequences may have higher stakes - both ranging from inconvenience to safety concerns. I don't consider this an over-reaction or "sky is falling", just trying to make the best of things in a new situation.

So inconvenience - I stepped in lots of things over the years, and I feel like dog poop is just tougher to deal with than anything else (especially with sneakers), and it's just not something I gave too much thought to in previous trips. I've never stepped in anything as tough to deal with as dog poop in my last 8 trips to Disney (or anywhere). So, maybe I bring an old pair of sneaks in case me (or more likely my kid) steps in something on the way to the bus in the morning. Don't want to waste time cleaning shoes.

Safety - I've never been on a group trip before, so I've never been to Disney with other people's kids. It was already something I was thinking about in a general sense. People parent differently, and Disney can bring out the worst in negative behaviors, so I had been thinking already about whether I would supervise other kids at the resort, etc. But I had mostly been thinking about tantrums, rudeness to other guests, pool safety, and such, hadn't considered a child wanting to interact with an unfamiliar dog, other than an occasional service dog. I mentioned a dog attack situation last year. I watched it all happen. To be clear, dogs are not allowed on school property at drop off/pick up. The owner of the dog (someone I know well), told the little girl to stay away, not to touch him, not to hover over him, etc., but the girl didn't listen, and the mom was too late to intervene. The owner is an animal lover, has many pets, volunteers in a shelter, etc. She knew the policy, and she had considered the situation might be stressful for this rescue dog. But her son was missing him during the school day, she thought it might be good for the dog, etc. She made an emotional decision, and not a rational one, and there were some pretty serious consequence for all involved. So, I may have to consider if I have my daughter's friend's little sister with me, will she listen if I tell her to give a dog space that may or may not be a little stressed out? I also have to trust that people have made rational choices in bringing their pet, both in the pet's best interest and in the interest of other guests.

I know my concerns won't change things, and I can't change my situation for this trip, I can only try to adapt. I really feel for people that have serious allergy or phobia concerns that have trips booked (and of course I'm wondering if that will include any of the 60 or 70 people in my group).
 
My wife is allergic to dogs, she comes out in a full body rash, that is in side her mouth, eye lids and private parts. Making her extremely uncomfortable.

As we are from Europe we have been to dog friendly hotels in the past, they have promised a deep clean and twice she has got sick there and she also got sick saying in one of the universal hotels 5 years ago. Which the pro dog team will keep saying are fine. Well they are not always fine.

She isn't allergic to dog hair she is allergic to the oils in there skin, this sinks into soft furnature, like seats, mattresses, pillows ect. You can't get rid of it.

We never would have booked a dog friendly hotel, which should be the end of the conversation. It wasn't dog friendly when we paid £2500 for the trip and now 14 days before we arrive it is. My wife is in tears she has been crying since Friday and simply doesn't want to go. She is shacking with fear that she is going to get that sick again.

We are going to celebrate her 30th birthday and celebrate me getting out of hospital after 4 months in a coma. This was meant to be our magical rest bite. I have sold guitars to afford to go and it's been 4 years since our last wdw trip.

This has been emotionally devistating to my wife who is going to the doctors this morning to have allergies jabs, which means she will miss 3 days of work and have here depression meds re-prescribed. She had come off of those meds recently due to planning and getting excited for this trip.

This decision has effected our plans

I think you should call Disney Reservations and explain what you explained here. They may try to move you to another resort. You have a legitimate reason for needing to change resorts. I also have had many health issues for the past four months. Because of that, I called yesterday and asked to be moved from POR to POFQ for the one night reservation we had, in light of the new dog policy. We are staying six nights at CBR but wanted one night at POFQ, our favorite resort. When I made the original reservation, there was no availability at POFQ so I opted for POR. I had booked the POR reservation at the time the special rates were out. When I called Disney yesterday, I asked if I could be moved and keep the special rate ($210) versus the $265 current rate at POFQ.

The CM was very understanding and after checking, said yes, she would move my reservation and yes, I would keep the same special rate. Granted, it was only one night, but it never hurts to ask.

I hope you and your wife have a wonderful vacation.
 
Last edited:
Attractions Magazine has a poll going with 1700+ people about the new policy and it's at 38% love it, 32% hate it, 30% don't care.
Others that I have seen pop up have been even heavier for in favor.
The DIS definitely does not represent the general population. This has always held true.

I doubt attractions magazine does either. That's the trouble with any of these unscientific surveys. But I know several people who are not on this board upset by this news. And I don't know anyone who is happy about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top