I love this thread....how does a day go by at the water parks without massive brawls amongst visitors.
Look folks...this thread is about etiquette...and you are never going to get total harmony and agreement, but let's pose a couple of questions. Understand these examples are really related, but just being used to show examples of etiquette:
1) If I am sitting at a restaurant with my family, is it OK for you to walk by my table, and take food off of my plate to eat? I'm guessing most of you would probably say No...well why not? Well, that food is in my possession, I supposed, but it is out in public, why not take it?
2) If I am at McDonald's alone with my DD5, and she needs to go to the bathroom, so I leave my Table to take her to the bathroom...tell someone on staff please don't throw away my food...what stops you from getting out of line and eating my meal that I left at the Table? Again, it's simply not acceptable behavior.
3) If I am at my resort, and I head to the pool and accidentally leave my room door ajar, does that make it OK for you to go into my room, use the bathroom, watch some TV, have a snack from the fridge? I would hope most people would agree this would be pretty rude. Bad etiquette, or is it tresspassing?
The point I am trying to make is: etiquette is not about what is legal or moral, but more what is considered generally acceptable behavior.
A lot of the agrument of why it is OK to take someones' chair that has their stuff on it is...well, people hog more chairs than they need or hog them for too long.
So, can we all agree that one piece of water park / pool etiquette is this:
"When entering the park and staking chairs, I will only stake out the minimum # of chairs that you need for your party. When I no longer need the chair, I will remove my stuff and give others access to it." Is this right? I think most would agree.
So, a second piece of etiquette, the one in contention, is: "If I place my stuff on this chair at the pool / waterpark, I should find when I return sometime later that my stuff will still be there and I will have access to the chair."
The argument I see primarily against this is that since people don't follow the first rule of etiquette - it invalidates the second rule of etiquette. But here's the thing with etiquette...following etiquette is irrelavant to whether other people follow etiquette...therefore, whether their stuff has been sitting there 5 minutes or 5 hours, if you move their stuff to take their seats, this is "bad etiquette", regardless of how their etiquette is. If someone is talking on their cell phone in the movie theatre (bad etiquette), that doesn't mean it is then OK for you to start yelling at them and throwing things (also bad etiquette).
As usual, I ramble on too long, so I'll stop here.
SkierPete