I was there New Year's Eve. We got to the park about 2:30 and knew it would be a long night, so DD8 and I got a last minute ADR for it. Food is very comparable to HDDR. Salad has a chipotle ranch instead of the Italian. Cornbread was jalapeno, which neither of us cared for. AND cold! The waitress brought us some rolls, I think, when she noticed my daughter wasn't eating the cornbread. DD loved the mac and cheese...just regular disney mac and chese that my kids adore. I remember being pleasantly surprised by the pulled pork. Brisket was dry, unfortunately because that is my favorite, had to add some BBQ sauce. Chicken had a great smoky flavor. The beans were very similar to HDDR.
Desserts were a platter of 3 different things. I was so stuffed I could barely fit any more in. I think there was a pumpkin cheesecake trifle that was delicious. Chocolate cake was typical cake. Apple dessert was good, but again too stuffed.
I see the menu now says cole slaw, but I definitely had salad. Our seasonal veg was broccoli. Service was slow, but it was NYE, so I expected that and I wasn't in a rush as we had a long ways to go till midnight.
If you like HDDR, you'll like this.