I agree with General Tso in that opinions for all character meals will be all over the map. It's very subjective. I think I am the
other lone person who is actually not a big fan of the Critter Breakfast.
I've never seen more than 5 characters there at one time, and sometimes only 4 (but that happens at
all the character meals except for Minnie & Friends, which consistently has 8-14 characters). The Critter Breakfast buffet selection is small. The menu selections are expensive for what they are and are only a few dollars less than the buffet (so the buffet makes much more sense). Picture something that's like the size of a Denny's Grand Slam...but it costs $18.00!!!
This is one of the few places where you can order a full-size Mickey waffle on the menu as well.
The characters I have seen over the course of a few visits have been some combination of: Koda, Kenai, Chip & Dale (but Chip & Dale can be found at Minnie & Friends or at Goofy's Kitchen), Terk, Meeko, Pluto (years and years ago - not sure why he was there), Rafiki and possibly Timon. I think Baloo was arriving as I was leaving at one point, but Baloo can often be seen at Goofy's. I have heard of some Br'er/
Song of the South characters popping in here and there but I've never seen them during my meals.
I prefer Storytellers so much more as a regular restaurant for lunch or dinner. But again, I am probably alone in my opinion. It's not that I think it is a
bad character meal or would advise anyone against eating there. It's just not my personal preference. You'd probably like it, though, because most folks do!