I agree with most other posters, stay where you want, as your DD will have fun in whatever resort& pool you choose. I will say, my DD absolutely Loved Polynesian when she had just turned 1. The kids interactive splash pad pool was really fun for her. She didn't care for the GF splash pad pool as much, and BWI held zero interest except that it was a pool. We have done BC a few trips with her too. The pirate ship small pool was fun, and we were able to let her go down the small slide there and catch her at the bottom. She also loved the play sand pool, but every time she got a ton of sand crystals in her swim diaper that really irritated her skin. We have not stayed at Contemporary. As far as pools and location together our favorite is Polynesian. Have a great trip no matter what resort you choose. A huge congratulations on the adoption anniversary!!!