We love via napoli...we thought the food (both pizza and pasta) is way better than at tutto. I love the quattro fromaggi and the pepperoni pizza. For pasta, my fave is candele. I get this almost every trip! And yes, we come here every single trip...its a must do for us.
FWIW, we've never gotten sick at via napoli. Many people do catch a norovirus/stomach virus and are quick to assume its food poisoning.