We were just there in Nov ... It certainly didn't seem "Run Down" to me ...
I think that generally speaking, those that end up being disappointed with the WL, dont care for the theming .... It's supposed to be kinda dark, rustic and woodsy. It' personally my favorite WDW resort.
It's supposed to be rustic....dark, flicker lamps...it adds to the nostaglia of the mountain lodges...if you want bright, white airy decor, go elsewhere..
We were just there this past January and then last September and 10+ trips before that...it's our favorite resort.....run down rooms, never seen one yet...everything has been perfect and we've been in alot of different rooms on different floors.....don't know what people expect.....
We've stayed at AKL and couldn't wait to get out of there....it was a split stay once with the Poly, (Poly didn't have all the nights we wanted so tried the split stay, first and last of those, with AKL first)...it's location dealing with the logistics with the whole WDW didn't appeal to us....how the resort was layed out was terrible depending on room location and as for animals from our Savannah view room, 2 or 3 for the 3 nights.....food offerings were not to our liking and the staff were unfriendly and cold....been there done that...and won't go back..
WL, on the lakes, fresh air from the water blowing in, boat ride to the MK and easy access to the monorail system via a boat to the CR....plus FW by boat...very realistic, themed well, compact with less day visitors, under one roof....well appointed rooms and housekeeping being the best we've ever had......always use Disney transportation and very few issues in all our trips...for us...it's the ideal vacation resort at a decent price (for a deluxe)..