We were on the 4/14 Western Fantasy cruise and we bought the Photo CD.
Between 2 cabins, there were 7 of us. Anytime we had to show a KTTW card, we used my husband's. We'd then have the 3 kids in the picture, then add in DH and I, and finally my parents. We even did a few of my parents alone. All of them ended up on our CD. In our folio, we even had duplicate prints a few times.
We paid the extra $50 to get all the prints as well as the CD. We had to empty our folio 3 times because it filled up! There is no way I could have gotten all the prints I wanted for $50, even taking them to WalMart to be printed.
As to the quality of the pictures, for the bulk of them, they were FABULOUS. We had a few that were just "so-so". Given what I've paid in the past to get family pictures done at home, the cost of the CD was worth it. We figured out that we had so many pictures on our CD that each one was only $2.
Also, on the Fantasy, the pictures on the CD now come with the different borders on them!
We love the CD and buy it every cruise!