Thanks which menu did you prefer?
@Mrtommorrow1987 Tough to say, there were courses that one did better over the other. Doing it for the first time I would definitely recommend Yuhi, super approachable with questions, quite talkative and explanatory, and pleasantly casual yet still professional. Ikei was very quiet but still personable if I had questions about a dish.
There was only one miss of a dish between the both of them for me which was the Ebi Carpaccio and Crab Thick Sauce for Ikei.
As far as highly memorable dished I came away with 3 from Yuhi (Kanpachi/Foie Dashi, Kuishi Oyster with Sakura Mignonette, Faroe Island Salmon Belly with Ramp Rice Porridge) and 3 from Ikei (Assorted Appetizers, Assorted Dim Sum, Pu-erh Dessert sans the Bao which I didnt love flavor wise)
Yuhi more closely followed the Kaiseki course pattern while Ikei's was more of a cantonese food tasting, at least that was a vibe I got from it, and certainly there was nothing wrong with that. If you are a dumpling fan definitely go with Ikei, the Sushi bar waitress who does all of the Omakase drink orders and the GM who came up to see how everything was going both stated he was the "dumpling master" of the establishment and it definitely showed with the Shangtang Soup and Assorted Dim Sum. We also had some of the staff up there periodically checking out what he Ikei doing because he seldom does Omakase and is usually on the line.
It also depends on what your plans are afterwards, I felt over-full from Yuhi's where I was able to head over to MK for after hours after Ikei's and traverse the park with only a mild over-full feeling which subsided after walking a bit but that also likely depends on the contents of the menu you receive. Towards the end Yuhi's french training/influence (he mentioned he trained under both Iron Chef French (Japan's) Hiroyuki Sakai before training under Morimoto) started to show through both the Scallops, Kami Nabe, and Ramp Porridge contained quite a bit of butter and there was loads of Ramp Porridge left and we were able to have seconds which was likely the major cause of the over-fullness.
It is the single best value fine dining experience in all of WDW, They could be charging $250 instead of $150 and I would still book it without hesitation. Its more casual yet oddly more intimate than Victoria and Albert's as the Chef's are cooking less than 3-4 feet from you for the majority of the meal.
Another nice option is if you have only a few people in your party ordering the omakase menu you can have the others in the reservation order from the regular menu a la carte while you enjoy Omakase but they can still be up there with you at the Sushi bar and they will try to pace the courses.