SAFD: A little late on this one.
DHS is responsible for one of my favorite park days and one of my least favorite.
Favorite: In September 2019 I went to DHS after arriving in on an early flight before the rest of my family arrived on our trip. My primary purpose was to scout Galaxy’s Edge and possibly come up with strategies for later in our trip. It was just a couple weeks after WDW GE opened and we thought it would be a madhouse. Whether it was the hurricane scare, GE fatigue from DL being open and RoTR not being open yet, time of year, or whatever other reason I’m missing, the park was far less busy than I could have imagined. Between 9:30 and 12:30 (before I left to go to Epcot for lunch at Food and Wine) I was able to ride Smugglers Run, explore all of GE, ride TSM, ride Slinky (FP+), ride ToT, and ride RnRC. It was pretty amazing.
Least: Wednesday of Marathon Weekend 2020. My sister and I woke at the crack of dawn and headed over to get a RoTR boarding group. Because the boarding groups are an impossibly terrible idea the whole park was packed to the gills at 6:30. We got a boarding group, but were unable to get into a line for another attraction before leaving for our intended park day at AK (the boarding groups eliminated the advantage of rope dropping by requiring everyone to rope drop
).
We got our boarding group notification at around 1 (we’d had a good day at AK and this was built into the plan) so we headed back. Well, the ride was breaking down all the time that day, so by the time we arrived 1:30-ish we found out it had been down for over an hour. We waited over another hour for it to reopen and finally got on 5 minutes before we had a hard out to make our dinner reservation (we had planned to hit the expo before dinner but had to go after). We were in DHS for over 3 hours that day for one attraction.
Overall: DHS has parts I really like, but it is #4 on my list for cohesive park experience. I love the individual attractions but there is no good overall flow to the park.
Hotter than hot take: RoTR is fine as a ride. Nothing special
Illuminati (patterns within patterns) take: RoTR is a lemon. The reason the boarding groups exist is because it’s so broke as a ride mechanism that they have to build in for the reality that it’s not working almost as much as it is. They can’t have people in a line because they can’t even come close to guaranteeing people will get through. I think they’d have just opened it and let there be an 8-hour line if it was reliable enough to know the line would move.