HELP! 5 night Fantasy vs 4 night wish

[dfan_welcomehomeall_19]

This right here. We have a 5 night on the Fantasy booked for next January for this exact reason.

We are booked Jan too!

 

[jrez]

At this point it's really just up to you since the factors you pointed out really don't matter.

I would pick the Fantasy cruise for these reasons:
1. Extra day (this doesn't appear to matter for you)
2. Layout, I prefer the Fantasy's especially Europa. The Wish's layout is overly criticized though
3. CC and LHP. I would love to go on a cruise that goes to both places.

I will say this about the Wish:
1. As a parent of a child in a wheelchair the Wish is more accessbile
2. I thought the meals in the MDRs is better, and Mickey's Festival of Foods is way better than Tow Maters.
3. The Fantasy is starting to show its age....just a little bit

 

[lscrivan18]

I would choose the Fantasy because the itinerary is more unique than Wish. On the Fantasy, I'd purchase a placeholder and use it to book a Wish cruise next.
As an aside, your children will be separated at the Kid's Club. They're currently keeping 3 and 4 year old's separate from the rest of the group. If you think the Wish kids club/slide to enter is something they definitely want to do together another reason to start with Fantasy first.

 

[Annabell]

I will choose the Fantasy, better itinerary and it is longer.

 

[Flcruising]

I don't get why your asking or even why it's a struggle. A hundred gets you an extra night on the Fantasy and lighthouse pt. It's a "Duh" question....unless you are playing with us . Enjoy your cruise

 

[dfan_welcomehomeall_19]

I don't get why your asking or even why it's a struggle. A hundred gets you an extra night on the Fantasy and lighthouse pt. It's a "Duh" question....unless you are playing with us . Enjoy your cruise

Well when you put it that way lol….

The struggle is/was brand new ship (fomo) vs older but better itinerary. Since most people prefer the fantasy, it seems that doesn’t even really matter

 

[Flcruising]

Well when you put it that way lol….

The struggle is/was brand new ship (fomo) vs older but better itinerary. Since most people prefer the fantasy, it seems that doesn’t even really matter

I do understand. We did the Wish once just to see but probably won't again unless the price makes it worthwhile. You recieved great responses so no need for me to add further. Have a great time.