We've stayed at basically every disney hotel and much, much, MUCH prefer Hard Rock to any. The rooms are huge compared to the dinky little spaces you get at disney for $300 a pop! Also the rooms are very bright and airy and CLEAN compared to the filth that we stayed in at WL one time. If I had to compare it, it would be to the GF, and given a choice I would pick the HRH.
For the $149/night that we spent for a 500+ square foot room (room 2101), we were absolutely delighted and will be back ASAP!!!!!
We loved walking to the resorts, loved the pool, loved the ambience.
It is a totally classy resort.