When sailing the Fantasy/Dream and not in concierge, we always book a Cat 4E extended balcony. We prefer Deck 5 forward, Starboard. The cabin is smaller (no murphy bed, no round tub and most only sleep 3) but the veranda is HUGE. 2 chairs, 2 mini-loungers and a table. We spend a lot of time on our veranda, so this is perfect for us. The aft extended balcony cabins do offer more privacy, but I'm prone to motion sickness and cannot be in an aft cabin, forward is much better for me in terms of motion.