Not "might be", they are. The FTC literally sued Amazon over this. Y'all must have missed this.
https://www.npr.org/2023/06/01/1179381126/amazon-alexa-ring-settlement
If y'all don't see the difference between MDE's app permissions and what Amazon was doing with Alexa and Ring until the government had to intervene, I don't know what to say. And if these shady undisclosed practices don't bother you then that's fine but don't act like people who have concerns are just ignorant luddites. There are very valid reasons that even many people who work in IT, myself included, keep their homes as "dumb" as possible.