There was no availability before they added this new category. I'm saying they should let people already booked at standard know it's now available for their dates in case they'd like to upgrade to that view - giving them the opportunity to have a pool/marina view for certain. Otherwise what is the point in now telling people they can't have their room request met because they didn't book that category if they aren't offering them that category?
Say all standard views are booked for October - which they are. All of us going should have received an email letting us know they added a new category. If we pay whatever amount more, we can get a guaranteed pool/marina view. Then anyone who wants to upgrade can, until those views run out. At that point, no complaining if you don't get the view you want, you got what you paid for. Fair is fair.
I would assume if they didn't do that, standard would still be getting marina/pool views, but we keep getting reports of people being told they didn't book that category when trying to get their room requests.