I am putting together a list of pros and cons for the two resorts on our list for our next trip.
We are thinking of WL CL now instead of CR CL due to budget...and we only had one experience with CL before when we were pixie dusted during our 5th anniversary (Poly) we got MK view Hawaii building, third floor...spoiled! It’s been a desire to stay CL again ever since.
In some ways, each CL is unique, but in other ways they are all quite similar. All of them are nice. Food is a tricky subject, because it is highly subjective, and because the CL food offerings change a bit randomly over time.
In my opinion, most CL breakfast offerings are very similar, except they never used to have eggs and only GF had cold cuts. BWI now- from what I have read- has some unique offerings, and AKL has some slightly unique offerings. IMO though, white bread is white bread, and muffins/pastries are pretty much muffins/pastries. The exact flavor isn't important. All CL's have breads, pastries, fruit, yogurt, often oatmeal, and assorted beverages.
It is the evening appetizers that vary the most between CL's, and vary the most over time. Between CR and WL, WL's are a little bit heartier and I like them better. CR tends to be more towards appetizer-style foods.
For desserts:. Again, WL tends to be a little heartier. I can't say for sure what you'll get, but they used to offer cobblers pretty often. Where CR's desserts tend to be a little fancier- more like little tarts, petit-four sized cakes, and shot glasses of layered cream style desserts (like mousse) with extra fancy chocolate sprinkles. Both are great, but I slightly prefer CR's.
WL -as a resort- has more fanciful theming and pool. WL feels like a great lodge in a national park. When I'm at CR, I know I'm in a hotel near MK. CR is a short walk to MK, WL is a bus or boat ride away. A fun boat but it takes a little longer than walking. Though CR's theming isn't exciting, IMO, it is very tranquil. It also has a nice view. A few WL tables are near a big window, but not as many.
Of the lounges, Poly, CR and the new CSR have the best theme park views. GF-main building has some partial view of MK and many windows. BWK, YC, AKL, GF-outer building, and BC don't offer much/any outdoor view. (BC has windows, but no real view of anything exciting.) AKL, WL, and GF-main building overlook (+ have nice view) of their hotel lobbies. GF-main has live music part of the day. I think all of the CL's have tv's. Sometimes they run cable news (ugh!), sometimes they run the WDW calendar, Disney cartoons, local news AM), weather, or something else (HGTV at BC).
Staff at all CL's are usually professional and quite nice, but this is also highly personal and subjective. Some are stellar, some are less personable, a few are maybe a little over-eager at times. (like clearing dishes too quickly as described above.)
All the CL's are worth a stay! That's perhaps the biggest risk; getting spoiled for CL!