I have said this a million times: Galaxy's Edge is Star Wars because Disney says its Star Wars.
Wizarding World in Universal Orlando works on almost every level because it is the familiar places people know and love from the books/movies. Galaxy's Edge doesn't really have that.
CarsLand is one of my absolute favorite places in Disneyland because you stand there and you absolutely feel as though you have been transported into Radiator Springs. It may not be absolutely 100% accurate to the movie, but standing there, especially at night with all the neon, it really feels as though you have stepped into the place from the movie.