Hi
We stayed in the Newport Bay in June 2002. I booked a non smoking room with a lakeview on the Admirals floor. It was our 25th wedding anniversary so wanted something a bit special.
When we arrived our room was not ready,when eventually we did get a room, it was on a smoking floor, and most definately did not have a lake view, in fact it had virtually no view.
I complained and eventually we were moved, this room was much nicer in fact it had a balcony and also a superb lake view. It was not on the Admirals floor (at least it had none of the extras ) but it was a room with a view so we were happy.
I have to say that we found the room to be smaller than we expected.
Other than the problem with the room we had a nice stay. Breakfast was really nice with a great view of the lake. The hotel was VAST, (I get lost very easily) by the time I found the pool my husband and son were on their way back to our room ! LOl
I certainly would recommend it, it was quite plush and had an "air" about it.
We stayed at the Cheyanne in 2003 and I have to say I preferred it. Not as plush as the Newport Bay but I loved it. The food court was rather busy and noisey but seemed to be part of the experience. Our son was more at home in the Cheyanne - it captured his imagination (The choice for breakfast was greater at the Newport Bay and of course you had the view too.)
We are going to stay at the SL in July so will have to see how it compares.
I guess that I would have to say that for us the Cheyanne had the edge over the Newport Bay and given the choice we would stay at the Cheyanne in future in preference to NB.