If they don't allow on the spot cancellations (for free) if the F! spots are gone, then this is clearly just a way to rope people into booking reservations they otherwise wouldn't. Blue Bayou isn't the place they would need to do that. It's always booked far in advance. However, Storytellers (for WOC) and River Belle seem like exactly the kind of places they would want to do that.
I am going to call the phone line on Thursday and hope the CM I talk to can shed some light on cancellations if dining packages are gone. I will report back if I have any useful info.
This monetization is all a bummer for me, regardless. Since it opened, I had been in the habit of getting a seat front and center against the fence, for free. The last time I went (aside from our trip last year) was 2006, and it still was free for everyone. This cash grab just feels like it was a first step towards the
Genie+ experience we have today. (I am aware these packages have been around for years.)