DCL Vibe versus RCCL Teen Clubs, Opinions?

[Mason3]

Does anyone have opinions on Vibe versus the teen clubs on RCCL? My DD, 15, loved Vibe, but we are considering a Southern itinerary on RCCL. I'm trying to find out if their teen clubs are as fun and nice as Disney's.

 

[DISNEY FANTASY]

Does anyone have opinions on Vibe versus the teen clubs on RCCL? My DD, 15, loved Vibe, but we are considering a Southern itinerary on RCCL. I'm trying to find out if their teen clubs are as fun and nice as Disney's.

We have been on RCI and my kids were that age they checked it out then refused to go as it was bad and they watched pay movies in the room

 

[AllThatJazz]

I've never myself been on RCCL, but I have plenty of friends that have. They all say they go to the clubs to meet teens, and then they never go back once they find their "group". There is not a lot of counselor/kid interaction nor a lot of planned activities.

Have a good cruise, no matter what you choose, they are both wonderful!