at this point with 20 DCL cruises (by year end) we keep coming back because (in no particular order)
1) They keep updating itineraries (kinda sorta) so we go to new places
2) Crew: we love interacting with them, the appear to enjoy interacting with us. On another cruise line most CM's would avert their eyes and NOT want to interact
3) Crew part Two: where else will you run across the "Scrape, Paint and Varnish" guys whistling Disney Tunes!!
4) Shows - Enjoy them. And most of the other entertainers they bring on board - and don't have to worry about random (continuous) F bombs
5) Staterooms are larger than what we experienced on a similar sized ship on a different CL
6) We love Disney Stuff. It's there, but it's also not Mickey ALL of the Time either.
7) Sorry
@Dug720 but I also enjoy Star Wars and Marvel (but I'm not going out of my way to do the "days at sea" either
8) Adult only areas
9) and on the other hand, there's a W-I-D-E age range on the ships that keeps it interesting. Unlike some other lines, there's not a majority of 20 somethings partying all of the time and worse yet, the ship is not 85% 70+ year olds. Been on that cruise when I was 52 and I felt that DW and I brought the average age down a LOT!
10)
Very Important: Service!! Get It a LOT from our Serving Team and Room Stewards.
Remember "Freestyle" means that You ARE INVISIBLE to the Crew - no one is "responsible" to take care of you and they don't really want to. They are getting their tips regardless because it was almost impossible to get them changed.
11) The DCL Fleet is CLASSY!! Not floating milk cartons
12) If you can afford to take a DCL cruise, You Don't need to take my stuff. Granted, I don't leave valuables laying around, but I don't worry about my stuff when I'm at the pool.
13) Smoke Free Interiors plus could care less about Casinos. And on the other ship we sailed - it seemed like you had to go through the casino to get anywhere - kinda like Atlanta and the South!
14) But --- We are getting to the point where the premium to sail DCL might be getting to be much too high. Will probably start exploring other cruise lines. RCCL might be a good option - wide range of ships, diversity in age of cruises, new itineraries.