lynzi2004
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2016
So we are planning our first family cruise (my DD and I have been on a girls trip with Carnival). DH, myself, and DD11, DS9, and DS5. We've got it narrowed down to a week in May. We have 2 options available to us and I'm not sure which to pick.
4 nights on the Wish out of PC...standard itinerary (Nassau/Castaway Cay). This was my first choice, the rooms look beautiful!
But then I got to digging around and I found this...
4 nights on the Magic as it relocates from San Juan to Miami...this goes to both St. Thomas and Castaway Cay. Its cheaper but after seeing the pics online of the Wish, the Magic looks dated.
I've read online reviews and the Wish seems to get a lot of negative feedback. But from what I can tell that's from repeat Disney cruisers, not first timers. What would you all suggest?!?
4 nights on the Wish out of PC...standard itinerary (Nassau/Castaway Cay). This was my first choice, the rooms look beautiful!
But then I got to digging around and I found this...
4 nights on the Magic as it relocates from San Juan to Miami...this goes to both St. Thomas and Castaway Cay. Its cheaper but after seeing the pics online of the Wish, the Magic looks dated.
I've read online reviews and the Wish seems to get a lot of negative feedback. But from what I can tell that's from repeat Disney cruisers, not first timers. What would you all suggest?!?