NotUrsula
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2002
My daughter just got 5 points taken off of a paper because she referred to Amelia Earhart as "she". Since my daughter never spoke to Amelia, her teacher wondered why she would be so "presumptuous" as to assume that is the pronoun Amelia preferred.
"Always go with 'they' until you speak with someone directly".
I really can't believe this is our world.
I'm all for learning to humor college professors who have power AND rather peculiar opinions about their subject, but this one crosses the line. Any instructor who tells a student to deliberately use incorrect grammar in an academic paper deserves to be burnt in effigy!
(And yes, I'm aware of the reason for it, and I still will not use it. I am an academic, but I refuse to use plural pronouns to refer to individuals. If I am told that X person prefers that pronoun, then I'm going to always refer to X by name.)