We had mixed results doing this last week. I almost didn’t want to elaborate because I don’t want to start a riot about it but this may be helpful so here goes nothing.
I booked FP before the system changed to paperless. I was able to change most FP’s so that all 6 riders in our party had them, except for SDD and FoP. I confirmed at least 6 times through various means of communications with a CM that we would all need FP and based on mixed results here, I decided not to chance it so I changed all of the ones I could still change. So, in my case we ALL did have a FP for all but 2 attractions and it was still a hassle.
The procedure:
At any ride where I asked for RS, hassle ensued, even if we all had a FP, and especially on rides where no one had a FP. This was at 7DMT, Alien Saucers, Space Mountain, Splash Mountain, Primeval Whirl, Thunder Mountain, Soarin’, Star Tours, Everest, and a few others I can’t even remember. All 6 had FP, I had 2 yo non-rider in stroller with me.
For each of the mentioned attractions, I had to ask CM stationed at FP entrance for a RS (normal so far). Then they would tap my magic band with a device the size of an iPhone, ask who was staying behind (I’d tell them I was), then they’d ask who was riding second and tap those two magic bands as well and give us a time to return by (sometimes as little as 15 minutes, sometimes as much as an hour).
Where it all falls apart:
The handheld devices often had to be rebooted. At Everest the CM told me she’d just let someone know we had RS. Well guess who wasn’t there when DH got off the ride? Yes-both the CM and the CM she supposedly told. So in more than one case we wasted time explaining and asking. We had a few cases where it must not have applied the RS because even though my older kids had their bands tapped as additional riders for my RS, their bands didn’t work (lit up blue, were told they didn’t have passes, more explaining and more time wasted.
Rides where all of us did not have FP:
SDD- we explained to the CM (as I was told to do when I initially contacted guest services for clarification when the system went paperless). CM asked if we all had FP, we told her (again) that 3 did and 3 did not. She stated that the person with FP (so DH) could be given RS and bring 2 people back. So older kids were put on RS as the second 2 people. DH then gave me his magic band so I could use his RS and take the kids with me. Well, his band didn’t work and we were told he already used FP and that because 3 of us did not have FP we would have to wait standby (apparently the handheld device had not worked yet again and we then spent more time explaining in the 100 degree heat).
FoP-explained to CM. RS was applied to my (non-FP having) magic band. Literally the ONLY time all week this went smoothly, but still with plenty of asking and explaining.
Bottom line is that I wouldn’t chance it anymore. It may still work sometimes right now but I saw plenty of CM’s explaining that it doesn’t work that way and so on.