If I am thinking correctly.....The one on Walnut ( it use to be Conestoga hotel??? Name changed in April 2001???) is the one we went to last yr... EXTREMELY RUDE staff and did not seem concerned when we pointed out problems- like the door that nearly fell on my 5 and 8 yr old...!!!! Had to remind them about the fridge request (smelly), had to wait 2 hrs to get into our room (computers were down), and while we were waiting I listened to one staff remark to manager in Spanish (trying to talk over my head so I would not understand --- hehehehehe -- I know some Spanish LOL) that he did not have a room for us. They had just barely cleaned our room when we finally got keys (this was 4 pm , check out is 11 am - also was a teusday - no excuse).... it is not walkable distance and the shuttle is shared between SEVERAL hotels - dropping in the furthest zone from the entrance (white cones), had to wait around alot for shuttles which were crowded at night.
Maybe it has improved???
The other two I have heard are better. The brand new one sounds interesting / nice - isn't it all suites?? It is a bit far but depends on shuttle service used.
The one on Harbor I have heard is decent as well - again not sure on shuttle service - I would contact them and ask where does shuttle drop off at ? (white is furthest away - blue and red are much closer)how often ? and how many hotels share it? - ours was on a lunch break every day for an hour and a half with no service, it was a pain to schedule our day around the shuttle times .....
Ypou could easily find a hotel that is closer for about the same price. Or even stay at Paradise Pier (on site) for $79- $99 a nite with Annual Pass rates ( Deluxe annual pass is very close to same amount as a 4 day hopper - plus you get discounts at many restaurants, stores, savings at Dsiney hotels...)