we watched this show years ago and actively disliked everything about it....
First recollections include-
The terribly uncomfortable seating
The length of the show
Being able to see the 'hidden' artistes on the stage
So; do we give it another try?
Do others enjoy?
Well, you already saw it once and didn't like it. So, definitely don't give up anything to see it again. But, if you have the time, and are inclined to give it a second chance... then why not?
That said...
We don't find the seating uncomfortable at all. If anything, I find the Lion King seating worse... but the show's so good I quickly forget about any discomfort I'm feeling.
We don't find the show particularly long, though the wait for it to start can sometimes drag because there's nothing to look at. (Nemo used to appear in the bubbles around the stage, but he seems to be on vacation lately.)
The performers are meant to be seen, though I can understand the confusion if this is not a familiar style of performance. There's two traditional styles of puppetry... one where the puppeteer is intended to be invisible, so either they're hidden behind the scenery or they wear black bodysuits. The other is a style in which the puppeteer is intended to be seen - they'll be dressed in bright costumes, matching their characters, and will be right out in the open. They also act, in addition to operating the puppets - using body language and expression to enhance the performance. The Lion King on Broadway was done in the second style, and Nemo is in the same tradition.
So... do you give it another try? Only if you want to.
Do others enjoy? Obviously!
We enjoy the show very much. That doesn't make you wrong, if you don't enjoy it, though. Everyone has their own tastes and preferences.