At what age is it no longer appropriate for kids to be pantless when company is over?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BLAZEY

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2006
Background: My mother hosted Sunday dinner last night. We ate outside, Mum now lives in a "Grannie Suite" attached to the main house my sister and I grew up in. DSIS and DBIL have bought 1/2 the house from DMUM. Attendees were DMUM, myself, DH, DD9, DAunt, DSIS, DBIL, DNephew5, DNiece3. We were carrying food out to the table and DH notices DNephew had a shirt, and sweatshirt on but no pants or shorts (he was wearing undies) DH asks him to go put shorts on as dinner will be ready soon. He says No, I don't have to. I reply "Your uncle has asked that you go put some shorts or pants on for dinner please go do it." This time DBIL overheard us saying the he needed to put pants on. DBIL agreed and told his son to put pants or shorts on for dinner. He goes upstairs. Comes down 5 minute later, no pants/shorts one. I tell him again, my DSIS is here now and says "he doesn't need to." My reply is DBIL told DNephew to put pants/shorts on." DSIS was a little huffy and said OK. DBIL backed me up and said if they "were at someone else's house he would have to have bottoms on. DSIS said "We're at home." DBIL replied "And there is company over. He is 5 and entering kindergarten in 3 weeks. He needs to learn new things as he's growing up." DSIS is still a bit upset that we (myself,DH, DMUM, DBIL) think that it's not appropriate for DNephew to be pantless at the table.

For the record I don't care what the rules are when it's just the 4 of them, but when company is over, the rules change. DD9 hasn't be less than fully clothed at the table since she was potty fully trained. DNeice 3 was fully clothed.

EDITED: DBIL (The child's father) has at previous occasions told said child to put pants on. EVERYONE else was in dressier clothes (button up shirts, khakis, or dresses)

UPDATE on page 8.
 
Last edited:
So you went to their house and decided how their children should be dressed and you and your dh both told their child to do something without speaking to his parents first?

Regardless of how I feel about when a child should be wearing pants, it isn't my place to tell them to put them on when I am in their home. I would speak to their mother or father and have them tell their child if they decide too.
If I didn't like their rules for their children when I am in their home then I am free to leave.
 


Background: My mother hosted Sunday dinner last night. We ate outside, Mum now lives in a "Grannie Suite" attached to the main house my sister and I grew up in. DSIS and DBIL have bought 1/2 the house from DMUM. Attendees were DMUM, myself, DH, DD9, DAunt, DSIS, DBIL, DNephew5, DNiece3. We were carrying food out to the table and DH notices DNephew had a shirt, and sweatshirt on but no pants or shorts (he was wearing undies) DH asks him to go put shorts on as dinner will be ready soon. He says No, I don't have to. I reply "Your uncle has asked that you go put some shorts or pants on for dinner please go do it." This time DBIL overheard us saying the he needed to put pants on. DBIL agreed and told his son to put pants or shorts on for dinner. He goes upstairs. Comes down 5 minute later, no pants/shorts one. I tell him again, my DSIS is here now and says "he doesn't need to." My reply is DBIL told DNephew to put pants/shorts on." DSIS was a little huffy and said OK. DBIL backed me up and said if they "were at someone else's house he would have to have bottoms on. DSIS said "We're at home." DBIL replied "And there is company over. He is 5 and entering kindergarten in 3 weeks. He needs to learn new things as he's growing up." DSIS is still a bit upset that we (myself,DH, DMUM, DBIL) think that it's not appropriate for DNephew to be pantless at the table.

For the record I don't care what the rules are when it's just the 4 of them, but when company is over, the rules change. DD9 hasn't be less than fully clothed at the table since she was potty fully trained. DNeice 3 was fully clothed.
When they're no longer in regular diapers, they need pants or skirts on.
 
Background: My mother hosted Sunday dinner last night. We ate outside, Mum now lives in a "Grannie Suite" attached to the main house my sister and I grew up in. DSIS and DBIL have bought 1/2 the house from DMUM. Attendees were DMUM, myself, DH, DD9, DAunt, DSIS, DBIL, DNephew5, DNiece3. We were carrying food out to the table and DH notices DNephew had a shirt, and sweatshirt on but no pants or shorts (he was wearing undies) DH asks him to go put shorts on as dinner will be ready soon. He says No, I don't have to. I reply "Your uncle has asked that you go put some shorts or pants on for dinner please go do it." This time DBIL overheard us saying the he needed to put pants on. DBIL agreed and told his son to put pants or shorts on for dinner. He goes upstairs. Comes down 5 minute later, no pants/shorts one. I tell him again, my DSIS is here now and says "he doesn't need to." My reply is DBIL told DNephew to put pants/shorts on." DSIS was a little huffy and said OK. DBIL backed me up and said if they "were at someone else's house he would have to have bottoms on. DSIS said "We're at home." DBIL replied "And there is company over. He is 5 and entering kindergarten in 3 weeks. He needs to learn new things as he's growing up." DSIS is still a bit upset that we (myself,DH, DMUM, DBIL) think that it's not appropriate for DNephew to be pantless at the table.

For the record I don't care what the rules are when it's just the 4 of them, but when company is over, the rules change. DD9 hasn't be less than fully clothed at the table since she was potty fully trained. DNeice 3 was fully clothed.

the rule
 


I do not think it’s appr for a 5 year old to be pant less with company over, and I would’ve said something (in a casual manner) to my BIL or SIL. It’s not my place to tell my nephew what to do unless someone is in danger.

Then again, ds20 and ds15 wear boxers around when other kids are over, the only one who thinks it’s wrong is me.
 
Regardless of whether or not I think whether my five year old nephew should have pants on, I would have asked his parents first before telling him to go put on pants.

What you have done here is shown that you aren't his boss and your directions can be countered by his parents. Good luck ever babysitting.
 
So you went to their house and decided how their children should be dressed and you and your dh both told their child to do something without speaking to his parents first?

Regardless of how I feel about when a child should be wearing pants, it isn't my place to tell them to put them on when I am in their home. I would speak to their mother or father and have them tell their child if they decide too.
If I didn't like their rules for their children when I am in their home then I am free to leave.
No we went to my mother's house.
 
Regardless of whether or not I think whether my five year old nephew should have pants on, I would have asked his parents first before telling him to go put on pants.

What you have done here is shown that you aren't his boss and your directions can be countered by his parents. Good luck ever babysitting.

I honestly thought my kid would be a nudist. He used to jump out at that age buck naked “surprise”. Yeah we corrected that.

I would never correct another persons child, even if I was related. If you have issues talk to his parents.
 
Regardless of whether or not I think whether my five year old nephew should have pants on, I would have asked his parents first before telling him to go put on pants.

What you have done here is shown that you aren't his boss and your directions can be countered by his parents. Good luck ever babysitting.
Actually I'm only one who will watch both of the kids together. My mum and the other grandmother refuse to watch both of them or even pick the up from school (totally different horror story). He is fine if DSis isn't around.
 
I honestly thought my kid would be a nudist. He used to jump out at that age buck naked “surprise”. Yeah we corrected that.

I would never correct another persons child, even if I was related. If you have issues talk to his parents.
I have spoken with DBIL (the father) he agrees with me. My sister overules her husband. This time he put his foot down.
 
I honestly thought my kid would be a nudist. He used to jump out at that age buck naked “surprise”. Yeah we corrected that.

I would never correct another persons child, even if I was related. If you have issues talk to his parents.
Mine too, I remember being at my moms (my kids practically lived there), and my BIL used to freak out when 3 year olds would run around in underwear after getting dressed from swimming or baths. He thought it was weird, until he had his own kids who were much more nudy than mine!
 
I thought you were going to say he was bare bummed.

What would you have said if he was wearing a speedo bathing suit?

We have a pants rule at our house (we’re also adults lol) but a five year old in his undies wouldn’t have phased me one bit.
 
Well, I am not a parent, so as per DIS rules, I probably am wrong or do not have a right to an opinion, lol!

For the record, I tend to be a rule follower. Does 5 seem a bit old to not wear pants? Perhaps. But the way the OP started the story, I was thinking the kid had NOTHING on, not even underwear. I mean if he was sitting at the table in a shirt with only his underwear, I would find it a bit odd. However, not sure I would have taken it upon myself to tell the kid what to do. I probably would have asked one of the parents about it, more from being a bit curious about it perspective.

OP, it is clear from the follow up posts that you have something going on with your sister in law and this pants issue is definitely related to that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!






Top