It's better because .............. it is.
I have stayed in all of them but AoA but have visited, eaten, toured suites etc.
AllStar Resorts are older and built first, POP built later and then AoA. I went to POP kicking and screaming because I was afraid it wouldn't be Disney enough, I mean if you are going for in your face values it needs to be Disney. I was pleasantly surprised and have around 35 stays there.
Differences with POP is that .........
.... POP footprint is slightly longer than say Movies, meaning there is
more green space between buildings. The landscaping at POP is noticeably above and beyond the AllStars ... feeling much
more lush and green, more like a moderate type of greenery. POP is built on a nice lake and many rooms look out to the
lake. It's like getting a deluxe view at value rates. I know many say you have no balcony but you don't at moderates either yet folks often book based on lake, river or garden views. POP guests have access to
AoA food court which is much better than all the other values and serves food on real plates with real silverware. POP has
three pools, with the two secondary pools quite large. There is never issues with lounges, tables or chairs. The
theme is a great mix of Disney and the decades including the decade timeline along the lake pathway. While POP has groups stay, it didn't use to, there seems to be less than stays at the AllStars. And of course now for those it is a perk, there will be a gondola.
For the most part I have never felt POP as crowded or busy and aware of all the other guests. I've stayed in rooms 11 days and never seen another person on our walkway. That hasn't been the case at AllStars. Not sure why, what the difference is, but am always aware of the people staying there ... maybe it's the buildings being closer to each other and how noise carries.
For AllStars rank:
#1 Sports, shocked me too but I like the footprint, the food court, the main pool area and have stayed in every section but football. I won't go back to Tennis again but loved Surf's up.
#2 Movies, only because it's movies but I generally avoid due to all the young families staying there and it was short greenery and too unshaded.
#3 Music, never again, I will stay offsite before I'd go back there. It's laid out like no others with the standards a long walk to front of resort, it's very dark and uncomfortable at night, I don't like being in the back and had only bad stays there.